Skip to content
Mr. GaryCabinet Painting

Guide · Colour

Choosing a cabinet colour: what my clients actually chose.

Cherry kitchen, wide view, after refinishingCherry kitchen, wide view, before refinishing

Recent kitchens I painted went to Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace OC-65, a warm “white chocolate”, Swiss Coffee, and white uppers with soft sage lowers. Choose the colour next to what stays (your counters, floor and backsplash) and look at your colour chip next to your counters, in morning and evening light.

By Gary4 min read

01

The colours clients actually chose

Four kitchens, four different answers to the same question:

  • Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace OC-65: a near-black espresso shaker kitchen in Westmount, August 2026. A bright, clean white against quartz counters.
  • “White chocolate”: a classic cream kitchen in Dorval with corbels, columns and lit glass uppers, September 2026. A warm white that suits the traditional details.
  • Swiss Coffee: a cream MDF kitchen with deep burgundy walls, May 2026. A soft off-white that freshened a kitchen that was already light.
  • White uppers, soft sage lowers: a dark cherry raised-panel kitchen in Montreal, July 2026, with the butcher-block island top kept natural.

02

Start from what stays

Painting changes the cabinets and leaves everything else. So the colour has to work with the counters, the backsplash, the floor and the walls you are keeping.

In Westmount the quartz counters stayed, and a crisp white made them read clean. In the cherry kitchen the natural butcher-block top stayed, and sage below kept the island warm next to it. Put your colour chips on the counter, beside the floor, and look at them there.

Westmount island and pendants, after refinishingWestmount island and pendants, before refinishing

03

Bright white or warm white

Going from dark wood or espresso to a bright white gives the strongest change. In Westmount the room reads twice as big with the same boxes. Dark to white needs a sealing primer, so that is part of the job from the start.

When a kitchen is already light, a warm white is the gentler move. The Dorval kitchen went from worn cream to “white chocolate”, and the Swiss Coffee kitchen from cream to a soft off-white. Both are quieter changes, and the whole kitchen reads fresher.

Dorval kitchen in “white chocolate”, lit glass uppers

04

Look at it in your own light

A white on a paint chip under store lighting and the same white on a whole wall of cabinets are different experiences. North light makes whites cooler; warm bulbs make them creamier. Look at your colour chip in the morning and in the evening, with the lights you actually use.

The sheen changes how a colour reads too, and a sprayed 2K finish has the same sheen on every door, so the colour reads the same across the whole kitchen.

Upper cabinet doors finished in Swiss Coffee

05

Two-tone kitchens

Different colours for uppers and lowers, or just for the island, work well when the room has enough light. Lighter on top keeps the room open; the colour goes below, where it grounds the kitchen.

The cherry kitchen with white and sage is the example on this site. Put the two colour chips side by side on your counter to decide the pair.

Cherry island, now soft sage below a natural butcher-block top, after refinishingCherry island, now soft sage below a natural butcher-block top, before refinishing

06

From colour to quote

You do not need a final colour to ask for a quote. Send photos with a free photo quote, tell me the colours you are thinking about, and we settle it before the colour coat goes on. The colour change service and the projects show more real before-and-afters.

A client’s words

“The cabinet colors look great and turned out exactly as discussed.”
Parimala Ranganathan. Quoted word for word, posted on Facebook.

Questions

Short answers.

Can uppers and lowers be different colours?

Yes. The cherry kitchen on this site went white on top and soft sage below.

Can dark cabinets be painted white?

Yes. Dark wood and espresso need a sealing shellac primer first, and then they can go white and stay white.

Can I choose a Benjamin Moore colour?

Yes. The Westmount kitchen was sprayed in Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace OC-65 with Renner Italia 2K.

Which white should I choose?

Look at a colour chip next to your counters and floor, in morning and evening light. Bright whites suit strong contrast; warm whites suit kitchens that are already light.

Do I need to decide the colour before the quote?

No. Send photos first; we agree on the colour before the colour coats go on.

Can only the island be a different colour?

Yes. A different colour for the island alone works well when the room has enough light.

Should I change the handles with the colour?

A colour change is a good moment to change the handles. If the new handles use different hole spacing, the old holes are filled before priming.

Fast first step

Send photos, get a straight answer.

A few photos of your kitchen tell me what your cabinets need. I look at them myself and come back with a free quote.

Get a Photo Quote